Why is the book always better than the movie?

Friend-“Hey did you hear?They’re turning (blank) into a movie!”
Me-“Oh yeah I’ve never heard good things about that. Maybe I’ll go see it.”
Friend-“Hold on, you haven’t read the book yet?”
Me-“No I haven’t.”
Friend-“Then you can’t see the movie until you read the book.”
Me-“What are you talking about? This is America and I’m over 18, I can see any movie I want.”
Friend-“Friendship over!”
Me-“Alright man I’ll see you in class.”

Okay maybe I’m exaggerating the dialogue but lets be honest, we’ve all had this conversation one way or another. Some people value the order in which you receive story, most of the time this means you have to read the book before you see the movie that the book becomes.Personally I feel that reading a story and seeing a story are to very different experiences and just because you see the movie before reading the book doesn’t make it any less of an experience. So why then do some people demand (not recommend but demand) that I receive narrative in ‘proper’ order?

I’ve been on both sides of this conversation but most of the time I find myself seeing movies without initially reading the book and I am judged harshly by friends, not ‘friendship over!’ harsh but you get the idea. Most of the time I find that reading the book before the movie gives me preconceived expectations for the movie that greatly effect the way I watch the film. I find myself constantly asking myself if the directors and writers of these films ‘ruined the story’ just because it didn’t match my single interpretation of how to tell the story.I think going into a movie like this, takes something away from the experience of watching the movie. As a director I know how hard it is to put a film together, it a collaberative effort takes hundreds of people to pull off, and its even harder when your turning a book into a movie because its so easy to accidentally get it wrong.

All I ask is that you as both a reader and a viewer not dictate the order of experiencing a story so harshly. Go into movies with an open mind and be open too different interpretations of the stories you hold in such high esteem. Maybe you’ll find that the movie might even be better than the book.

2 thoughts on “Why is the book always better than the movie?

  1. I agree with you completely. I personally love watching movies and have a great appreciation for film. Even if I’ve read the book before I still enjoy/ appreciate the movie. I think movies and books are different from each other. I think film directors add in certain scenes or changes certain scenes so they fit the screen.

  2. I choose not to compare books and movies too often. A movie is a totally different experience than a book because it is a visual effect. A book is subjective to each and every reader. However, the aspects of the way both stories are told can be compared. For example, the book described a petite women with blonde hair and the movie featured a tall brunette.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s